Skip to main content

Pie

Black Bottom Oatmeal Pie

A filling of bittersweet chocolate, dark corn syrup, and rolled oats make this a rich, delicious pie.

Spiced Kabocha Squash Pie

This aromatic alternative to pumpkin pie calls for fresh (not canned!) squash and a new twist on the classic crumble topping. If you'd like some sparkle on the edge of your crust, brush it with a beaten egg and sprinkle with coarse sugar before baking.

Brown-Butter Pecan Pie With Rum and Espresso

Brown butter brings out nuttiness of the pecans, while the bite of rum and the slight bitterness of espresso balance out the sweetness of this pie.

Spiced Custard Pie with Sesame Crust

One of the most important steps in making custard is making sure the sugar is fully dissolved into the yolks. Be sure to beat them together until pale yellow ribbons form, since the sugar acts as a shield for the yolks, preventing them from curdling when you add the hot cream.

Caramel Apple Pastis

This beautiful pastis — a sweet phyllo-wrapped pie that evolved in southwest France from the savory meat-filled _b'stilla_s of Morocco — makes an impressive holiday dessert.

Bourbon-Brown Butter Pecan Pie

Shortening makes for the flakiest pie crust. But you won't miss the buttery flavor-there's plenty in the filling.

A Bigger, Crustier, Easier Blueberry Pie

It's called a slab pie, and it will change the way you think of pie forever.

Coconut Custard Pie

Shredded, sweetened coconut acts as both flavoring agent and lone sweetener in this baked custard pie.

Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie

This quintessential spring pie has the perfect combination of strawberries, rhubarb, cinnamon, and a delicate, flaky crust.

Red, White, and Blueberry Pie

A pile of red and blue berries tops off a cloud of white whipped cream in this blueberry-filled bit of glory

Cherry Buttermilk Clafoutis

Sweet-tart cherries elevate the otherwise straightforward custard, and buttermilk lends a welcome tang.

Nectarine, Plum, and Raspberry Pie

Just about any fruit will work under this delicious lattice crust, but the sweet-tart trio of nectarines, plums, and raspberries is hard to beat.

Sour Cherry Pie

An addition of almond flour gives this pie crust a nutty, toasted flavor—a great complement to the sour-cherry filling.

Italian Rice Pie (Pastiera di Riso)

Italian wheat pies—filled with a rich ricotta custard studded with tender wheat berries—are associated with Easter celebrations, but according to author Gina Marie Miraglia Eriquez, rice pies are just as classic and in her estimation, taste better. Eriquez had been making wheat pies for years when she had some extra dough a while back and used it to make a rice pie. "My family went berserk. They went crazy for it!" said Eriquez with a laugh. "Rice is more tender. It has a nicer taste than wheat," she explained. "If you give my family a choice, they're going to ask for the rice before the wheat." The pastry dough, pasta frolla, is delicate and tears easily, so if it softens, quickly chill it in the freezer for a few minutes. And don't worry about the tears; they patch easily.

Chocolate Cookie Crust

Editor's Note: Use this crust to make Allison Kave's Nutella Pie .

Rhubarb Frangipane Pie

For some, the beginning of spring is marked by budding crocuses and blooming daffodils. For me, it's all about the rhubarb. After a long winter of baking endless nut, citrus, and chocolate cream pies, the emergence of those leafy pink stalks from the ground is a harbinger of the coming bounty of spring and summer fruits. Some wait until strawberries are in season a few weeks later to start baking with rhubarb, but I use it as soon as humanly possible. Toasted almond frangipane is a lovely, creamy foil to the tartness of the rhubarb, and adds an extra layer of flavor without overwhelming the star ingredient.

Nutella Pie

If you've never tried Nutella, that ambrosial combination of hazelnuts and chocolate, put this book down right now, run to your nearest grocery store, and buy a jar. Bring a spoon along to expedite the Nutella-in-mouth process. OK, now that we're all on the same Nutella-obsession page, I'll proceed with a recipe that will make you fall into an incoherent puddle of babbling ecstasy, while simultaneously making you the most popular of all your friends (if you can bring yourself to share). What's more, this is a speedy, incredibly easy one to whip up, so you don't have to delay your satisfaction for too long.

Elvis Pie

The King (otherwise known as Elvis Presley) was known for his swiveling hips, his dreamboat eyes, his smooth crooning, his ridiculous sequined jumpsuits, and his eccentric palate. One of his favorite snacks was a grilled peanut butter, banana, and bacon sandwich, which to some might sound obscene, and to others (me), obscenely delicious. This pie marries the sweet, smoky, salty, nutty flavors of Elvis's favorite sandwich in a rich, gooey, messy cream pie. Fresh banana pudding, topped with peanut butter whipped cream in a peanut butter¿bacon cookie crust. Need I say more? You probably only need to eat this once in a lifetime; you'll never forget it.

Cornmeal Crust

Editor's Note: Use this crust to make Allison Kave's Rhubarb Frangipane Pie . This crust has a more grainy, toothsome texture than a classic crust, and the natural sweetness of cornmeal makes a great accompaniment to summer pies such as blueberry or cherry. Use this when you want a truly rustic pie.

Spinach Pie

Mary Fitzgerald, Wexford: Gardener and internet enthusiast Three generations of my family have eaten this dish: we used to make it to use up my father's seasonal harvest of spinach. I now grow spinach in my own garden, along with everything from sorrel and runner-beans to beetroot and rhubarb, and make this pie regularly.
15 of 64